ASEAN Last-Mile: Ninja Van (SGD 4/parcel) vs J&T (SGD 2.80) vs In-House (SGD 6) = Margin Leak
Ecommerce brand: 3K parcels/month. Ninja Van SGD 4 = SGD 12K/month. J&T SGD 2.80 = SGD 8.4K/month. Saving by switching: SGD 3.6K/month = SGD 43.2K/year. But J&T success rate 88% vs Ninja Van 94% = 6% more failed deliveries = SGD 504 extra redelivery cost + customer complaints. Net saving: SGD 3.1K/month. AskBiz models total delivery cost including re-attempts.
The Last-Mile Cost Breakdown#
Last-mile is 30-50% of total logistics cost. Components: base rate (per parcel), fuel surcharge (2-5%), remote area surcharge (2-8 SGD for rural), failed delivery fee (SGD 1-3 per re-attempt), COD handling fee (1-1.5% of order value). Most merchants compare only base rate. Total cost including surcharges: Ninja Van SGD 4.80 effective, J&T SGD 3.40 effective, Ninjavan premium service SGD 6.20.
Success Rate vs Cost Trade-off#
Failed delivery is expensive: courier re-attempts (SGD 1.50-3 each), customer frustration (3-5% don't reorder after failed delivery), return cost (parcel returned, SGD 2-4 return fee, re-ship SGD 4+). Ninja Van: 94% first-attempt success. J&T: 88%. For 3K parcels: Ninja Van 180 failures, J&T 360 failures. Extra J&T failures: 180 × SGD 4 total cost (re-delivery or return) = SGD 720 extra. Minus base rate saving SGD 3.6K = J&T net saving SGD 2.88K/month.
Not all zones are equal.
Zone-Based Optimisation#
Not all zones are equal. J&T strong in Indonesia (88% → 93% success rate in Jabodetabek). Ninja Van stronger in Singapore CBD (97% success). Split strategy: J&T for Indonesia and rural Malaysia (lower base rate, adequate success), Ninja Van for Singapore and urban Malaysia (higher success rate justifies premium). Reduce total cost by SGD 1.5K-2K/month vs single carrier.
Data-backed guides on AI, eCommerce, and SME strategy — straight to your inbox.
AskBiz Delivery Cost Analytics#
Tracks per-courier: base cost, surcharges, failed delivery rate, re-attempt cost, customer complaint rate. "Last month: Ninja Van 1.5K parcels, total cost SGD 7.2K (SGD 4.80 effective), success 94%, net cost/delivered parcel SGD 5.11. J&T 1.5K parcels, total SGD 5.1K (SGD 3.40 effective), success 88%, net SGD 3.86. Rebalance: shift Singapore orders to Ninja Van (SGD 4.80 justified by 94% success). Shift Indonesia to J&T (success similar, SGD 1.60/parcel saved). New blended cost: SGD 4.20 vs current SGD 4.10 — but Indonesia success improves, total re-delivery cost drops SGD 600/month."
- Ecommerce brand: 3K parcels/month.
- Ninja Van SGD 4 = SGD 12K/month.
- J&T SGD 2.80 = SGD 8.4K/month.
People also ask
How do I negotiate better rates with couriers?
Volume is leverage. At 500 parcels/month, limited negotiation. At 2K+, approach Ninja Van/J&T account manager directly. Request volume tier pricing. Commit to 3-month minimum for best rate. Typical negotiated saving: 10-20% off standard rate.
Should I ever use in-house delivery?
Only if your delivery zone is very tight (e.g., same neighbourhood) and order volume is high (100+ daily in that zone). Otherwise, fixed cost of driver, van, insurance exceeds SGD 6/parcel. Third-party couriers are almost always cheaper below SGD 10M revenue.
Our team combines expertise in data analytics, SME strategy, and AI tools to produce practical guides that help founders and operators make better business decisions.
Optimise Last-Mile Delivery Cost (Save SGD 2K-4K/Month)
AskBiz tracks total delivery cost including surcharges and re-attempts. Recommends courier mix by zone. Try free.
Connects to Shopify, Xero, Amazon, QuickBooks, Stripe & more in minutes